The ruling party Morena has declared the recent election of judges as a significant step in Mexico's democratic journey, asserting that increased elections signify enhanced democracy. President Claudia Sheinbaum proclaimed Mexico as the world's most democratic nation, despite a mere 13% voter turnout. The election was described as "historic" and "successful" by Morena's leaders, who dismissed low participation criticisms by highlighting the uniqueness of the event.

Morena emphasizes Mexico's pioneering move to elect its judiciary through popular vote, arguing that this historic event sets the nation apart globally. The reform aims to address issues such as nepotism, corruption, and privilege within the judiciary, promising a closer alliance with the populace rather than the elites. However, the effectiveness of these elected judges remains to be seen.

Former President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, the mastermind behind the judicial reform, participated in the voting, underscoring the unprecedented nature of the election. He reflected on the historical significance of citizens directly electing judicial officials, expressing pride in Mexico's democratic state. Despite his vow to retire from politics, his influence on these elections remains profound.

The judicial election emerges from López Obrador's frustrations with federal judges and Supreme Court ministers who obstructed key infrastructure projects, prompting him to replace them through democratic means. This judicial reform became a central theme in the previous presidential elections, contributing to Sheinbaum's victory and Morena's legislative dominance.

Official narratives interpret last year's high voter turnout as a public mandate for judicial reform, though Sunday's low turnout challenges this view. Sheinbaum celebrated the election as a recognition of universal rights and empowerment of the working populace, insisting on Mexico's increasing freedom and justice.

Sheinbaum and López Obrador critique past judicial selection processes as elitist, contrasting them with the current popular election model. The reform is portrayed as a shift towards true democracy, where every vote holds equal weight in shaping national destiny.

Morena leader Luisa María Alcalde reinforces the belief that popularly elected judges will foster a more independent judiciary. She has criticized the opposition's calls for abstention, claiming their aversion to democratic principles and public decision-making.